Approved only if no listed class does the work, the class is used in the area, and the rate bears a reasonable relationship to listed rates. Silence is not approval. 29 CFR 5.5(a)(1)29 CFR 5.5Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR(iii).
When you need a conformance
A wage determination lists the classifications WHD had enough data to publish. When the work on your job falls outside every listed classification, the contract clause at 29 CFR 5.5(a)(1)(iii) requires the contracting officer to have that class of workers “be classified in conformance with the wage determination”. The WH-347 instructions say the same from the payroll side: if no classification fits the work a worker did, contact the contracting officer or agency representative immediately.
Check two things first. Look under every identifier, since one union code can cover several trades (see how to read a wage determination). And look for SC identifiers: since the 2023 rule, WHD may list rates for frequently conformed classifications directly on the wage determination (29 CFR 1.3(f) and 5.5(a)(1)(ii))29 CFR 1.3Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR29 CFR 5.5Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR. DOL's rule FAQ says “These rates will apply to the applicable classification without the need to submit a conformance request.” The same FAQ adds that if there is a real question whether a listed classification does the work in the area, the agency should still submit a conformance request.
Conformance is for a missing classification, not a wrong rate. If you think a listed rate is too high or too low, that is a challenge to the wage determination, which must be made before award (see how rates are set).
The three criteria
All three must be met (29 CFR 5.5(a)(1)(iii)(A))29 CFR 5.5Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR:
- “The work to be performed by the classification requested is not performed by a classification in the wage determination”;
- “The classification is used in the area by the construction industry”; and
- “The proposed wage rate, including any bona fide fringe benefits, bears a reasonable relationship to the wage rates contained in the wage determination”.
And one limit: “The conformance process may not be used to split, subdivide, or otherwise avoid application of classifications listed in the wage determination.” A request for a lower-paid sub-trade of a listed classification will be denied.
Test 1: is the work already covered?
The Resource Book chapter on conformance sets out how WHD answers the first question:
- Is the requested classification already on the wage determination for the right county and construction type? If so, use it.
- Do the duties fall within one or more listed classifications? If the contract has several wage determinations, look only at the one for that part of the project; you may not borrow a classification from another schedule in the contract.
- Is the listed classification that might cover the work a union rate or an SU (survey) rate? That decides whose practice counts: union contractors for a union rate, the mix of contractors behind the average for an SU rate.
- Is there evidence that workers in the listed classification did these duties on similar construction in the area during the year before bid opening or award? Under the Fry Brothers decision, the practice of the sector whose rates were found prevailing controls.
- If there is such evidence, the request is denied and the listed classification applies. If not, move on to the rate.
A union's claim that its agreement covers the work is usually not enough for work outside core craft work; WHD looks for specific projects and contractors. In American Building Automation (ARB Case No. 00-067), a request for a building automation technician was denied because plumbers had done that work on area projects.
Test 3: a reasonable rate
If the work is not covered, the proposed rate is compared with the rates on the same wage determination, following AAM 213:
| Proposed classification | Compare with |
|---|---|
| Skilled craft | Other skilled classifications (not laborers, truck drivers or power equipment operators) |
| Power equipment operator | Other power equipment operator rates |
| Laborer | Other laborer rates |
| Truck driver | Other truck driver rates |
WHD then looks at whether union or non-union rates predominate within that category and sets a rate in line with them. If some skilled rates on the wage determination are below laborer rates, the Resource Book says the agency should generally use only skilled rates above the laborer rates. Appeals cases summarized in the Resource Book show how this works: in Terrebonne Parish (2020), WHD looked only at the union rates because six of nine skilled rates were union, and the Board held that contractors may not rely on rates approved in earlier conformances. A rate set for another contract or under a state or city schedule does not count; the comparison is with the wage determination in your contract.
The process, step by step
- The contractor or subcontractor spots the missing classification, ideally at the pre-construction conference and before the work starts.
- The contracting officer gives the contractor Form SF-1444 (on SAM.gov and in the FAR at 48 CFR 53.301-1444).
- The contractor fills in the classification, duties and proposed rate and fringe. The contractor and, if known, the workers or their union sign (Blocks 14 to 16).
- The contracting officer reviews it against the criteria, notes any disagreement, and signs with a recommendation. “No action will be taken on the request if the agency does not sign” and state its position.
- The contracting officer emails a single PDF to DBAconformance@dol.gov with the SF-1444, supporting papers and a copy of the contract wage determination. “WHD policy requires the submission of the contract wage determination with the conformance request.”
- WHD approves, modifies or disapproves within 30 days of receipt, or says it needs more time.
- The contracting officer tells the prime contractor. The contractor gives each affected worker a copy or posts it with the wage determination at the site.
- Every worker in the classification is paid at least the approved rate from the first day of that work, with back pay if needed.
If the contractor, workers and contracting officer agree, the contracting officer sends a report of the action (29 CFR 5.5(a)(1)(iii)(C))29 CFR 5.5Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR. If they do not agree, the contracting officer refers the question with everyone's views and a recommendation, and WHD decides (paragraph (D)). Either way, the approved rate “must be paid to all workers performing work in the classification under this contract from the first day on which work is performed in the classification”.
While you wait
Silence is not approval. The Resource Book: “Lack of a DOL response within 30 days does not mean that the request has been approved.” In Swanson's Glass, the appeals board held that the 30-day period is not jurisdictional and that a contracting officer's sign-off does not bind DOL. If WHD sets a higher rate than you paid, you owe the difference back to day one.
Keep a record of the hours each worker spends on the unlisted work from the first day, so back pay can be figured if needed. The contracting agency can check status with the WHD Branch of Construction Wage Determinations analyst for the state.
Apprentices, helpers and welders
Apprentices. No conformance is needed. “Rates for apprentices are not listed on Davis-Bacon wage determinations.” Registered apprentices are paid under 29 CFR 5.5(a)(4)29 CFR 5.5Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR; see Davis-Bacon apprentices and helpers.
Helpers. Conformance of a helper is generally approved only if the duties are clearly defined and distinct from every listed classification, helpers are an established prevailing practice in the area, and the helper is not a trainee in an informal program.
Welders. Usually no conformance. “Welding is commonly considered incidental to the work of workers for whom classifications are issued.” The welder gets the rate of the craft whose work the welding supports, though a separate welder sub-classification may sometimes be conformed.
Reconsideration and appeal
An interested party can ask the WHD Administrator to review a conformance decision under 29 CFR 5.1329 CFR 5.13Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR, after an optional second-level review by the Branch of Construction Wage Determinations. A final ruling of the Administrator can be appealed to the Administrative Review Board under 29 CFR part 729 CFR part 7Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR. Labor standards disputes are not handled under the contract's general disputes clause. Clean energy credit projects use a different channel for additional classifications: see supplemental wage determinations for clean energy projects.
Questions filers ask
Who submits a Davis-Bacon conformance request?
The contracting officer. The contractor prepares the SF-1444 and signs it, but the agency signs, adds its recommendation and emails it to DBAconformance@dol.gov.
How long does DOL take to approve a conformance?
29 CFR 5.5(a)(1)29 CFR 5.5Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR(iii) says WHD will act within 30 days of receipt or tell the contracting officer that more time is needed. The Resource Book says WHD responds to most requests within 30 days.
What rate do I pay before the conformance is approved?
The approved rate applies from the first day of work in the classification, so any shortfall becomes back pay. Track the hours from day one.
Can I reuse a classification DOL approved on my last job?
No. Appeals board decisions summarized by DOL say contractors may not rely on rates approved in earlier conformance requests; each request is measured against the wage determination in the current contract.
Can I conform a cheaper classification for part of a trade's work?
No. The conformance process may not be used to split or subdivide a listed classification (29 CFR 5.5(a)(1)(iii)(B))29 CFR 5.5Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR.