Misclassification tops DOL's list. No time record by class means the highest rate for all hours; fringe credit is per worker, never an average; unfunded plans need DOL approval first (29 CFR 5.28)29 CFR 5.28Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR. The prime is liable for subs. DOL Fact Sheet 66; 29 CFR 5.529 CFR 5.5Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR.
The errors DOL names
DOL's Fact Sheet 66 lists the compliance issues that come up most often on Davis-Bacon projects. First on the list is “Misclassification of laborers and mechanics.” The rest:
- Not paying the full prevailing wage, including fringe benefits, for all hours worked, overtime included.
- “Incomplete or inaccurate recordkeeping, such as not counting all hours worked or not recording hours worked in each classification” by a worker in two or more classifications in a day.
- Not keeping a copy of the apprenticeship program and each apprentice's registration.
- Not submitting certified payrolls weekly.
- Not posting the Davis-Bacon poster and the wage determination at the site.
What a payroll reviewer checks
Agencies must review certified payrolls in a timely manner (29 CFR 5.6)29 CFR 5.6Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR. DOL's investigation chapter tells reviewers to “Check for completeness and accuracy of the certified payrolls as to the names, classifications of work performed, hourly wage rates”, daily and weekly hours, gross wages, deductions and net pay. It also tells them to compare rates against the wage determination, look for a disproportionate number of laborers or apprentices, check fringe contributions and cash in place of fringes, and verify apprentice ratios day by day. Run the same checks before you sign.
Wrong or missing classification
The classification must match the work the worker actually did, whatever the job title. Classification disputes are settled by local area practice, not by your own job descriptions. See how to read a wage determination.
If the work has no matching classification on the wage determination, do not pick the nearest one and move on. The WH-347 instructions say to “contact the Contracting Officer or Agency representative immediately”. The missing class is added through conformance, and the conformed rate applies from the first day the work was done.
Split work without a time record
Paying a worker two rates for two kinds of work is allowed only when your records show the time in each. If they do not, the WH-347 instructions are strict: “the worker must be paid for all hours worked using the highest applicable prevailing wage rate (basic hourly rate and fringe benefits)”. On the WH-347, show each classification on its own row with the same worker entry number.
Fringe benefit mistakes
Fringe errors are the hardest to spot on the face of a payroll. The usual ones:
| Mistake | The rule |
|---|---|
| Taking credit at an average rate for the whole crew | Credit is per worker. “It is not permissible to take credit based on the average premium paid or average contribution made per worker.” |
| Putting cash in lieu of fringes in the hourly rate column | The WH-347 instructions for column 6A say: “do not include cash payments in lieu of fringe benefits in this column”. Cash goes in 6C. |
| Claiming credit for an unfunded plan without approval | Credit for benefits the contractor provides directly needs DOL's prior approval under 29 CFR 5.2829 CFR 5.28Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR. |
| Counting your own administration costs | A contractor's own costs of running benefits are business expenses, not creditable fringe benefits. |
| Crediting a plan the worker is not eligible for | No credit for contributions on behalf of workers who cannot participate in the plan. |
| Column 6B does not match page 2 | 6B should equal hours worked times the total hourly credit listed for that worker on page 2. |
Annualization and creditable plan types are covered in Davis-Bacon fringe benefits.
Overtime under the CWHSSA
On contracts over $100,000 covered by the Contract Work Hours and Safety Standards Act, hours over 40 in a workweek must be paid at least time and a half of the basic rate. The common mistake is counting only the hours on this project. The WH-347 instructions say to report as overtime hours over 40 “(including hours worked on and off the site of the work of the covered contract)”. Missed CWHSSA overtime also brings liquidated damages for each worker for each day. See Davis-Bacon overtime and the CWHSSA.
Apprentice errors
An apprentice rate is allowed only for a worker individually registered in a registered program. DOL's investigation chapter says “Any worker listed on a payroll at an apprentice wage rate, who is not registered or otherwise employed as stated at 29 CFR 5.5(a)(4)(i)29 CFR 5.5Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR, must be paid not less than the applicable wage rate” on the wage determination for the work performed. Two more traps: the ratio of apprentices to journeyworkers is checked each day, not each week, and a contractor working outside its program's area must follow the ratio and wage rates of a program covering the job's locality. See Davis-Bacon apprentices.
Deductions
Every deduction must fit the Copeland Act rules. The WH-347 instructions say “Except for deductions listed in 29 CFR 3.529 CFR 3.5Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR, all deductions must have prior approval from the Department of Labor.” The 3.5 list includes tax withholding and other deductions required by law, certain court-ordered payments, and voluntary contributions that meet its conditions. If a deduction is not allowed, box 6 of the Statement of Compliance is false. See payroll deductions on Davis-Bacon jobs.
Form and filing errors
| Error | Fix |
|---|---|
| Full Social Security numbers on the weekly payroll | Use an identifying number such as the last four digits; keep the full number in your records. |
| Scanned, copied or faxed signature | Sign each week by hand or with a legally valid electronic signature. |
| Wage determination number left blank or out of date | List every wage determination and modification number that applied to the work that week. |
| Box 4 checked with no apprentices, or box 5 left blank when claiming credit | Check box 4 only for apprentices; check box 5 and complete the grid when claiming a plan credit. |
| Payroll numbers out of order or no final payroll marked | Number from 1 in order; mark the final box for your last week on the project. |
| Late or missing weeks | File within 7 days after payday; a missed payroll can lead to payment suspension. |
Details for each field are in the WH-347 line-by-line guide, and the six boxes are explained in the Statement of Compliance guide.
How to fix a mistake
When you find an underpayment, pay it. The contract clause makes the prime and the responsible subcontractor liable for unpaid wages and monetary relief, “including interest from the date of the underpayment or loss”. Then correct the payroll records, and tell the prime or the contracting agency what changed and when the workers were paid. The rules we hold do not set a standard format for a corrected certified payroll, so ask the agency how it wants the correction shown and keep proof of each make-up payment.
- Find the scope: every worker and every week the error touched, including subcontractors.
- Compute the shortfall for each worker, rate by rate and hour by hour, plus interest.
- Pay the workers and keep proof of payment.
- Correct your records and send the agency or prime the corrected information in the form it asks for.
- Fix the cause: the time-keeping, classification or fringe setup that produced the error.
Fixing a mistake helps, but it does not erase the past. DOL tells contracting officers that “in no event should a contractor be left with the impression that the payment of back wages will eliminate the possibility of debarment”. Debarment is aimed at disregard of obligations, such as falsified payrolls, repeat violations and clear misclassification. If you refuse to pay, the agency can withhold contract payments and DOL can withhold across your other covered contracts; see withholding and debarment.
Questions filers ask
What is the most common certified payroll mistake?
DOL's Fact Sheet 66 lists misclassification of laborers and mechanics first among the issues it sees most often on Davis-Bacon projects.
What if a worker did two kinds of work and I only tracked total hours?
Without an accurate split by classification, the worker must be paid the highest applicable prevailing rate, basic rate and fringe, for all hours worked.
Can I average fringe benefit costs across my crew?
No. DOL says credit must be figured for each worker and may not be based on an average premium or contribution.
Do I owe interest when I pay back wages?
The contract clause makes the contractor liable for unpaid wages and monetary relief, including interest from the date of the underpayment.
Does paying back wages stop debarment?
Not necessarily. DOL tells contracting officers that payment of back wages does not eliminate the possibility of debarment.
A sub's payroll is wrong. Is that my problem as the prime?
Yes. The prime is responsible for subcontractors' compliance and liable for back wages a subcontractor does not pay.