SCA: federal service contracts over $2,500. Davis-Bacon: federal construction contracts over $2,000. The agency decides first, WHD rules finally; appeals go to the ARB (part 7 DBRA, part 8 SCA). 29 CFR 4.11629 CFR 4.116Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR; FAR 22.402FAR 22.402Federal Acquisition Regulation, acquisition.gov.
Where the line is drawn
The SCA exempts “a contract of the Federal Government or the District of Columbia for the construction, alteration, or repair, including painting and decorating, of public buildings or public works” (41 U.S.C. 6702(b)(1))41 U.S.C. 6702United States Code, Cornell LII. That is the same language Davis-Bacon uses for its coverage in 40 U.S.C. 314240 U.S.C. 3142United States Code, Cornell LII. 29 CFR 4.116(a)29 CFR 4.116Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR explains the purpose: “The intent of section 7(1) is simply to exclude from the provisions of the Act those construction contracts which involve the employment of persons whose wage rates and fringe benefits are determinable under the Davis-Bacon Act.”
So the two laws are meant not to overlap. Work that Davis-Bacon does not treat as construction stays under the SCA if the contract is mainly for services. DOL's Resource Book notes that agencies decide which law applies to each part of a contract, and that getting it wrong can mean cost adjustments later. For the general test, see which prevailing wage rules apply and Davis-Bacon coverage.
Maintenance vs repair
The Resource Book says alterations and repairs, including renovation and rehabilitation, are construction, while “routine maintenance and preventative work is a service covered by the SCA, assuming all other SCA coverage requirements are met”. It gives these signs:
| Points to SCA maintenance | Points to Davis-Bacon repair |
|---|---|
| Routinely scheduled, continuous or recurring | Not recurring; fixes individual problems as separate incidents |
| Keeps the building or work in its current condition | Restores or improves it by replacing, overhauling or reprocessing parts or materials |
| Does not improve condition or function | Improves strength, stability, safety, capacity, efficiency or usefulness |
| Items done relatively quickly | Individual items take longer |
| Skills not typical of the construction trades | Skills typical of the construction trades |
Examples. Changing HVAC filters and lubricating motors every month on a schedule is SCA maintenance. Replacing a failed rooftop unit is repair under Davis-Bacon. Weekly cleaning of gutters is maintenance; replacing a section of roof is construction.
Demolition, drilling and cleanup
Demolition depends on what comes next. “SCA applies where the contract is for the demolition or dismantling of buildings or other structures, and no further construction activity is contemplated at that site.” Davis-Bacon applies if future construction is contemplated there, or if the removal itself alters the facility; the Resource Book's example is removing asbestos or paint from a building that will stay. Whether construction is contemplated turns on facts such as plans or surveys, funding applications, bid solicitations and what officials have said.
Drilling follows the same logic. Soil boring for foundations and drilling water or oil wells are construction. Exploratory drilling for engineering data, drilling for planning when the construction is not authorized or funded, and temporary holes for samples are SCA services.
Cleanup, landscaping, carpet laying and drapery installation are Davis-Bacon work when done as part of new construction before the owner accepts the building. “The SCA applies when the same activities are performed after the construction contractor and subcontractors have finished and left the site, and the contracting agency has accepted the building.”
Contracts with both kinds of work
A contract principally for services can still carry Davis-Bacon for its construction part. Under 29 CFR 4.116(c)(2)29 CFR 4.116Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR and FAR 22.402(b)FAR 22.402Federal Acquisition Regulation, acquisition.gov, Davis-Bacon generally applies to the construction work when two things are true:
- The contract requires a substantial amount of construction, or it is clear that substantial construction will be needed. “the word "substantial" relates to the type and quantity of construction work to be performed”, not merely its dollar share of the contract; and
- the construction is physically or functionally separate from the other work and can as a practical matter be performed on a segregated basis. It need not be convenient to award separately, only separately identifiable in the contract.
The Resource Book's examples: a cafeteria services contract that also requires renovating and painting the kitchen, and a base support contract with substantial, segregable work orders such as painting housing, refinishing floors or reroofing. The SCA clauses and wage determination then govern the service work and the Davis-Bacon clauses and determination govern the construction. 29 CFR 4.116(c)(1)29 CFR 4.116Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR gives the reverse case too: a contract to install an alarm system and then maintain it for a year carries Davis-Bacon for the installation and the SCA for the maintenance.
Task orders and service calls
On a hybrid contract, each work order is sorted with the maintenance and repair factors. Defense contracts have bright lines, which the Resource Book cites from the DFARS: “Individual service calls or orders which will require a total of 32 or more work-hours to perform shall be considered to be repair work subject to the DBA.” Painting of 200 square feet or more under one call or order is Davis-Bacon work regardless of hours, and contracting officers may not split tasks between orders to avoid Davis-Bacon. When Davis-Bacon applies to an order, the certified payroll rules apply to it.
How the two laws differ
| Rule | Service Contract Act | Davis-Bacon |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | 41 U.S.C. 670141 U.S.C. 6701United States Code, Cornell LII to 6707 | 40 U.S.C. 314140 U.S.C. 3141United States Code, Cornell LII to 3148, plus the Related Acts |
| Threshold | Over $2,500 | Over $2,000 |
| Federally assisted work | Not covered | Covered when a Related Act applies |
| Workers | Service employees | Laborers and mechanics on the site of the work |
| Wage determination | Attached per contract; renewed at options, anniversaries and extensions | General determinations by area and construction type; see how to read one |
| Fringe benefits | Usually one health and welfare rate for all classes plus vacation and holidays | A fringe amount per classification |
| Extra cash wages count as fringe? | No (29 CFR 4.170)29 CFR 4.170Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR | Yes |
| Pay frequency | At least semi-monthly | At least weekly |
| Weekly certified payroll | No; records kept for 3 years and shown on request | Yes, weekly (Form WH-347 or equivalent) |
| Successor union rates | Yes, section 4(c) | No equivalent rule |
| Overtime | CWHSSA or FLSA | CWHSSA or FLSA |
| Debarment | 3 years (41 U.S.C. 6706)41 U.S.C. 6706United States Code, Cornell LII | 3 years (40 U.S.C. 3144)40 U.S.C. 3144United States Code, Cornell LII |
Two rows trip up contractors who do both. On fringe, DOL's Fact Sheet 66E says “Under the DBRA (unlike the Service Contract Act), cash wages paid in excess of the BHR may be used to offset the fringe benefit portion of a contractor's prevailing wage obligation.” On payroll, Fact Sheet 66 says that on Davis-Bacon work “Contractors are required to pay covered workers weekly and submit weekly certified payroll records to the contracting agency”. The SCA clause, FAR 52.222-41(i)FAR 52.222-41Federal Acquisition Regulation, acquisition.gov, requires records but no weekly submission, and 52.222-41(j) allows pay periods up to semi-monthly. Details: SCA health and welfare, Davis-Bacon fringe benefits, the WH-347.
Overtime is the same on both: the CWHSSA requires time and a half over 40 hours a week for laborers and mechanics, including guards and watchmen, on covered contracts over $100,000 (40 U.S.C. 3701)40 U.S.C. 3701United States Code, Cornell LII, and the FAR puts its clause in contracts above $200,000 since October 1, 2025 (FAR 22.305)FAR 22.305Federal Acquisition Regulation, acquisition.gov. See overtime and the CWHSSA.
The wage and benefit amounts in the worked examples on this page are made up to show the arithmetic. Use the rates in the wage determination attached to your own contract.
Workers who do both in one week
A maintenance mechanic on a hybrid base contract may spend part of a week on SCA maintenance and part on a Davis-Bacon repair order. Keep hours by contract part and by class. On the SCA side, without records the highest applicable rate is owed for all hours (29 CFR 4.169)29 CFR 4.169Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR, and unsegregated work is presumed covered (29 CFR 4.179)29 CFR 4.179Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR. On the Davis-Bacon side, the construction hours go on that week's certified payroll at the Davis-Bacon rate and fringe.
Example. A mechanic works 24 hours of scheduled maintenance at an SCA rate of $26.00 plus $5.92 health and welfare, and 16 hours replacing a boiler pump under a Davis-Bacon order at $38.00 plus $14.00 fringe. Pay: 24 x $26.00 = $624.00 in SCA wages, 16 x $38.00 = $608.00 in Davis-Bacon wages, and fringe of $224.00 (16 x $14.00) on the Davis-Bacon hours. SCA health and welfare is owed on the hours paid on the SCA contract: 24 x $5.92 = $142.08. Only the 16 Davis-Bacon hours go on the WH-347.
Who decides
The contracting agency decides first which law applies to each part of a contract, with help from its labor advisor. The Resource Book adds that “WHD has the authority to issue final determinations on coverage.” Final WHD rulings can be appealed to the Administrative Review Board under 29 CFR part 729 CFR part 7Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR for Davis-Bacon and part 8 for the SCA. If a solicitation labels repair work as maintenance, ask the contracting officer before you bid. DOL's chapter on determining which labor standards apply and 29 CFR 4.116 have the full text.
Questions filers ask
Is building maintenance covered by the SCA or Davis-Bacon?
Routine, recurring maintenance that keeps a building in its current condition is SCA work. Repair that restores or improves the building, using construction trade skills, is Davis-Bacon work.
Can one contract have both SCA and Davis-Bacon wage determinations?
Yes. A service contract with substantial construction that can be performed separately carries Davis-Bacon for that work and the SCA for the services.
Is demolition covered by the SCA?
Only when no further construction is contemplated at the site. If construction is planned there, or the removal alters a building that stays, Davis-Bacon applies.
Do I file certified payroll on an SCA contract?
Not weekly certified payroll as on Davis-Bacon work. You must keep the records 52.222-41 lists for 3 years and make them available to WHD.
Can I pay extra wages instead of fringe benefits?
On Davis-Bacon work, yes. On SCA work, no: the fringe obligation must be met with benefits or separately recorded cash.
Who decides which law applies?
The contracting agency first; WHD makes final coverage rulings, which can be appealed to the Administrative Review Board.