Over-ratio hours count in total hours, not apprentice hours. Foremen, superintendents, owners and exempt staff are left out. IRC 45(b)(8)IRC 45Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII; Treas. Reg. 1.45-8Treas. Reg. 1.45-8Treasury regulations, eCFR.
The three tests
Section 45(b)(8) and Treas. Reg. 1.45-8 set three tests for every credit with the full PWA rule (30C, 45, 45Q, 45V, 45Y, 45Z, 48, 48C, 48E and 179D). The new home credit (45L) and the nuclear credit (45U) have no apprentice test. As with wages, the owner carries the risk: “The taxpayer is solely responsible for ensuring that the Apprenticeship Requirements are satisfied.” This page is general information, not tax advice.
| Test | What it requires | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Labor hours | Qualified apprentices perform at least the applicable percentage of total labor hours | 45(b)(8)(A); 1.45-8(b) |
| Ratio | Apprentice hours count only within the apprentice to journeyworker ratio, each day | 45(b)(8)(B); 1.45-8(c) |
| Participation | Each employer with 4 or more workers on the construction employs at least 1 qualified apprentice | 45(b)(8)(C); 1.45-8(d) |
The labor hours requirement
The applicable percentage depends on when construction of the facility began:
| Construction began | Apprentice share of total labor hours |
|---|---|
| Before January 1, 2023 | 10 percent (but see the January 29, 2023 exception) |
| In 2023 | 12.5 percent |
| After December 31, 2023 | 15 percent |
Labor hours are all hours of construction, alteration or repair work by anyone employed by the taxpayer, a contractor or a subcontractor, with one set of exclusions: “Labor hours do not include hours worked by foremen, superintendents, owners, or persons employed in bona fide executive, administrative, or professional capacities” (as defined in 29 CFR part 54129 CFR part 541Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR). Count the hours of every tier: the EPC contractor, the electrical sub, the civil sub and anyone the owner hires directly.
“The percentage of total labor hours is calculated on a per qualified facility basis”, so you track hours per facility, not per company or per contract. Hours worked before January 29, 2023 are excluded under the transition rule (Treas. Reg. 1.45-8(a)(2))Treas. Reg. 1.45-8Treasury regulations, eCFR.
Classroom time is not labor hours. In the regulation's Example 5, apprentices spent 500 hours in off-site training: “The hours spent on classroom training at a location other than the location of the qualified facility in preparation for the construction, alteration, or repair of the facility are not considered labor hours performed by qualified apprentices.”
Doing the math
Treas. Reg. 1.45-8(b)(1)Treas. Reg. 1.45-8Treasury regulations, eCFR, as corrected in August 2024, describes the calculation by aggregating all hours and dividing by apprentice hours. The worked examples in the same regulation all compute it the plain way, apprentice hours divided by total hours, and so does this page:
- Total labor hours (all tiers, excluding foremen, superintendents, owners and exempt staff), for example 40,000.
- Required apprentice hours = total x the percentage. At 15 percent: 40,000 x 0.15 = 6,000 hours.
- Counted apprentice hours = apprentice hours within the daily ratio, plus hours covered by a good faith effort.
- Shortfall = required minus counted. If counted is 5,400, the shortfall is 600 hours.
The apprenticeship labor hours calculator runs these steps for you, with the percentage set by the construction start year.
The ratio requirement
Under Treas. Reg. 1.45-8(c)(2)Treas. Reg. 1.45-8Treasury regulations, eCFR, the ratio of apprentices to journeyworkers on the job site, in each occupation and classification, on any day, must comply with the registered program's ratio under 29 CFR part 2929 CFR part 29Code of Federal Regulations, eCFR. If you work outside the area where the program is registered, use the ratio that applies where the work is done; if there is none, use the program's own ratio. Over-ratio hours still count, but only on one side of the fraction: “the labor hours performed by any qualified apprentice in excess of the ratio may not be counted as hours performed by qualified apprentices for purposes of the labor hours requirement”, while they are added to total labor hours.
The ratio also sets pay. Over-ratio apprentices must be paid the full journeyworker rate under the prevailing wage requirement. The ratio is checked daily, so you need daily crew records by classification, not just weekly totals.
The participation requirement
Section 45(b)(8)(C) says each taxpayer, contractor or subcontractor that employs four or more individuals on the construction “shall employ 1 or more qualified apprentices to perform such work”. The count covers the whole job: the rule applies “regardless of whether they are employed at the same location or at the same time”. A small sub that sends three people in March and two different people in June has employed five and needs an apprentice.
The penalty for missing this test is heavy because it is figured on the failing employer's average worker hours, not the shortfall: that employer's total hours divided by its number of workers, times $50. In the regulation's example, a contractor with five workers and 17,000 hours created a 3,400 hour shortfall, a $170,000 penalty. See fixing PWA failures.
Who is a qualified apprentice
A qualified apprentice is employed by the taxpayer, a contractor or a subcontractor and is participating in a registered apprenticeship program (Treas. Reg. 1.45-8(g)(8))Treas. Reg. 1.45-8Treasury regulations, eCFR. That means the person has a written apprenticeship agreement and is registered with DOL's Office of Apprenticeship or a recognized State apprenticeship agency while doing the work, or is in the first 90 days of probationary employment and certified as eligible. Pre-apprentices, trainees in unregistered programs and helpers do not count. Programs the employer sponsors itself count, as do joint and non-joint programs.
When the tests apply
Only to construction before the facility is placed in service. The IRS FAQ says: “There are no apprenticeship requirements with respect to alterations or repairs after a facility is placed in service.” The regulation's Example 3 makes the same point for a repair two months after the facility went into service: “Taxpayer C did not fail the Apprenticeship Requirements because the Apprenticeship Requirements do not apply after the qualified facility is placed in service.” Prevailing wages still apply to that repair work for credits with an alteration or repair period.
Worked examples from the regulation
| Example (Treas. Reg. 1.45-8)Treas. Reg. 1.45-8Treasury regulations, eCFR | Facts | Result |
|---|---|---|
| (e) Example 1 | Start April 2023 (12.5%). 17,000 hours; four apprentices worked 4,000 hours but only three journeyworkers on site at a 1:1 ratio | Only 3,000 apprentice hours count; 3,000 / 17,000 = 17.6%, test met |
| (e) Example 4 | Start April 2023 (12.5%). 50,000 hours, 6,250 apprentice hours within ratio | 6,250 / 50,000 = 12.5%, test met |
| (e) Example 5 | Start January 2024 (15%). 50,000 hours, 7,000 apprentice hours, plus 500 classroom hours | 7,000 / 50,000 = 14%; classroom hours do not count; test failed |
| (f)(2) Example 4 | Contractor R had five apprentices and four journeyworkers at a 1:1 ratio; 19,800 total hours | 400 over-ratio hours do not count; 2,400 counted vs 2,475 required; 75 hours short, $3,750 penalty |
If you fall short
Two ways out keep the increased credit. First, the good faith effort exception: hours you requested from a registered program that were denied, or not answered within 5 business days, count as if apprentices worked them. Second, the cure: pay the IRS $50 for each labor hour short, or $500 per hour if the failure is due to intentional disregard (Treas. Reg. 1.45-8(f)(2))Treas. Reg. 1.45-8Treasury regulations, eCFR. Unlike the wage penalty, this penalty is subject to deficiency procedures. Work under a qualifying project labor agreement owes no apprenticeship penalty. The shortfall and penalty are reported on Form 7220.
Planning apprentices on the job
- Estimate total labor hours by trade before bidding, and set the apprentice hours target (15 percent for 2024 and later starts).
- Write the target, the participation rule and the duty to forward apprentice requests into every subcontract.
- Find registered programs that cover the site's area for each trade; you will usually need more than one.
- Send written requests at least 45 days before apprentices should start; use the request deadline tool.
- Track daily crews by classification so you can prove the ratio, and total the hours monthly so a shortfall shows up early.
- Keep the agreements, registrations, requests and responses with the payroll; see PWA records.
For apprentice pay rates and ratios on federal Davis-Bacon contracts, which follow DOL's rules rather than the IRS's, see Davis-Bacon apprentices.
Questions filers ask
How many apprentice hours do I need?
For a facility whose construction began after December 31, 2023, 15 percent of total labor hours on that facility; for 2023 starts, 12.5 percent. Example: 40,000 total hours x 15% = 6,000 apprentice hours.
My sub has five workers. Must it hire an apprentice?
Yes. Any taxpayer, contractor or subcontractor that employs four or more individuals over the whole construction must employ at least one qualified apprentice, even if the workers were never on site at the same time.
Can I count apprentices above the ratio?
Their hours count in total labor hours but not as apprentice hours, and they must be paid the journeyworker rate.
Do foremen and superintendents count in total hours?
No. Labor hours exclude foremen, superintendents, owners and exempt executive, administrative and professional staff.
Do apprentice rules apply to repairs after commercial operation?
No. The apprenticeship tests apply only to construction before the facility is placed in service.
Do 45L homes need apprentices?
No. The 45L new home credit and the 45U nuclear credit have only the prevailing wage requirement.